MPR's Nuclear Experience
Background
The U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) significantly changed its rules for license renewal
when it issued the Maintenance Rule (10CFR50.65) in July 1991, and the License Renewal Rule
(10CFR50.54) in May 1995. These rules are more objective and realistic than the former requirements
for license renewal, and this action by the NRC has encouraged utilities to reconsider the
possibility of license renewal for their nuclear plants. Additional factors favoring license renewal
include:
- Need for generator capacity--Although there is a national surplus of electric generation
at this time, the combination of utility and IPP construction is not keeping up with demand, and
generation is expected to tighten up in 5-10 years.
- Competition--Existing nuclear plants can be cost repetitive in a market driven economy
because, in many cases, the marginal production costs (fuel and O&M) are considerably lower for
nuclear plants than for existing coal-fired plants or even new high-efficiency gas turbine combined
cycle plants.
License Renewal, therefore, is economically attractive for nuclear plants that can maintain high
capacity factors over the long term.
Qualifications and Expertise
MPR Associates, Inc. has a history of over 30 years of providing engineering services to the
commercial nuclear power industry. This work has included numerous material condition evaluations
for nuclear and fossil fueled generating stations, as well as generic aging assessment work for the
industry: MPR authored EPRI Report TR100844, Nuclear Power Plant Common Aging Terminology,
November 1992.
MPR has extensive experience in solving challenging technical problems that threatened the useful
life of major components, for example:
- Reactor Vessel Nozzle Penetrations--Development, analysis, and testing of roll repairs
for reactor coolant system nozzles, and for control rod drive system stub tubes
- Reactor Vessel Internals--BWR core shroud repair (patented), and PWR internal bolting
failure evaluation
- Steam Generators--Assessment of tube remaining life, and development of insitu corrosion
monitoring instrumentation for SG chemical cleaning (patented)
- Pressurizer--Metallurgical evaluation and development of repair of Alloy 600 stress
corrosion cracking in heater sleeves
- Containment--Developed BWR drywell sandbed repair, and BWR torus corrosion
assessments and recommended repairs
MPR recently completed an Aging Management Review Component Supports for a two-unit PWR, In
performing this review,
MPR used a commodity approach, on the basis that component supports perform basically the same
function regardless of the system with which they are associated. Treating component supports as
commodities, as opposed to performing the aging management review for each individual component
support within the scope of license renewal, resulted in a cost-effective approach for this portion
of the plant's Integrated Plant Assessment for license renewal.
Another important cost-effective feature of the component support review was the use of existing
programs, especially the recently-completed USI A-46 (seismic verification) program. MPR's knowledge
of the scope of the A-46 program, which used the Seismic Qualification Utility Group (SQUG)
earthquake experience-based methodology, allowed us to evaluate the program scope and provide the
technical justification required to credit A-46 work as a key element in the aging management
program for component supports.
License Renewal Services
MPR can help utilities to:
- Perform plant material condition reviews and assess the technical and economic justification
for continued operation and license renewal.
- Solve challenging technical problems that could limit plant life, e.g., reactor core shroud
cracking reactor internal bolting failures (PWR).
- Develop creative, cost-effective approaches to license renewal, e.g., commodity approach to
component support aging management review.

Contact
For further information on License Renewal or other services provided by MPR Associates, contact:
Caroline Schlaseman, PE
or Will Grant
More MPR Nuclear Experience